Quality, Innovation & Originality
You are currently in: Home > Project Archive > Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative (2004-2006)

Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative (2004-2006)

The European Commission's Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative was a three year project that concluded in August 2006. This unique project benchmarked different aspects of 45 participating European Cities’ transport systems. By exploring and comparing best practice examples of urban transport delivery in cities across Europe, the initiative has enabled a greater understanding of how to make urban transport strategies work more effectively.

The website for the above project is no longer maintained.

In the past TTR have project coordinated a high number of projects, and the website has been an important element for disseminating project information. This particularly project has now come to an end and the website is no longer maintained. To prevent the lost of project information, documents & reports the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initative project is recorded here - The TTR Project Archive.

If you need any further details please contact TTR (enquiries@ttr-ltd.com)

Contents

About Benchmarking
What is Benchmarking / Benchmarking and Urban Transport / Previous Benchmarking Initiatives
Urban Transport
Project Objectives / Project Timescale / Project Management / Indicators and Themes

Working Groups

Disabled People / Social Issues / City Logistics / Cycling / Demand Management / Organisation & Policy
Publications, Reports & Outputs
Press Releases & Brochures / Reports / Benchmarking Tool /  Final Conference

 

 About Benchmarking
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifWhat is Benchmarking?

The concept of benchmarking has been used widely by many different types of organisation seeking to learn more about their operational shortcomings. The process of benchmarking involves comparing operational performance with similar institutions, organisations or enterprises in order to gain some understanding of the best practices employed within a given industry. Once performance differences across an industry are understood then each participating organisation has the potential to integrate best practices within the scope of its own operations in order to attain measurable performance improvements.

Successful Benchmarking =
Self Analysis + Identify Best Practices + Analyse Performance Differences + Implement Findings
Result = Narrowed Performance Gaps & Tangible Performance Improvements

The benchmarking process is usually centred upon performance indicators, which operate as a means of self analysis and help to identify key differences between participating organisations. The participants of a benchmarking exercise will collect data for these indicators in order to establish best practices in a particular field. Site visits or case studies are often used to showcase best practices, because this helps participants to understand more fully how the best practices have been developed and how they work on a daily basis.

Once the benchmarks have been established all that remains is for individual participants to return to their respective organisations and implement the process changes that should improve performance levels. This requires a commitment from participants that the organisation is willing to co-operate not just in the process of benchmarking, but in following up the recommendations in order to implement change. This is not simply a case of “following the leader”, but of constructively integrating the best practices that leading organisations have established into existing procedures.

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifBenchmarking and Urban Transport

This project sought to apply the benchmarking concept to the urban transport systems which are present in cities across the EU and the Accession countries. This is in keeping with the European Union's policy approach which places considerable importance upon the role that attractive, efficient, local and regional transport systems can play in the economic development and social cohesion of the EU. In the field of urban transport the exchange and promotion of best practices is one of the main policy tools that the European Commission possesses. The Urban Transport Benchmarking initiative therefore attempted to compare the differences between the participating cities' transport systems in order to identify and promote best practices in urban transport.

The benchmarking concept has great potential when applied to urban transport systems and within the context of this project, which was realized in this project. Previous initiatives have often followed a tried and tested path, which this project utilized but by no means adhered to previous conventions. By narrowing the focus of this study, the benchmarking process provided more comparable results than in previous initiatives and improved upon the set of data which was used to monitor urban transport improvements across Europe. This involved the development of more practical data indicators, which aided the learning process for the organisations involved in the project, as well as improved the robustness of the best practices which were identified and promoted.

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifPrevious Benchmarking Initiatives

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative adhered to the European Commission's subsidiarity principle by including as many urban transport stakeholders as possible. The process of Urban Transport Benchmarking was therefore very fluid, responding to the issues which were raised by urban transport stakeholders, rather than following a rigid process which has been predetermined. In this way the subsidiarity principle was fulfilled, because the recommendations about urban transport best practices were made by a network of urban transport operators, user groups, local authorities and municipalities, rather than a single centralised institution. The project's findings therefore provide a useful resource for other urban transport stakeholders and help them to implement innovative solutions to common urban transport problems. 

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative built on the experience of the two previous Citizen's Network Benchmarking Initiatives which together ran from 1998 until 2002. The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative sought to learn from the experiences of previous transport benchmarking projects rather than ignore them.

 

Urban Transport
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifProject Objectives

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative aimed to continue and build on the work of the Citizens Network benchmarking project and was closely connected with the ongoing development of CIVITAS and the CIVITAS forum.
The objectives were:

  1. To select annually a group of participants representing local and regional urban transport stakeholders from 35-40 cities
  2. To agree a set of common performance indicators covering urban passenger and freight transport
  3. To undertake a comparative analysis across stakeholders
  4. To set up a maximum of 5 thematic working groups on topics agreed by the participants
  5. To organise site visits (3 per year) for the working groups through which to identify and study best practices
  6. To disseminate the results.

The project addressed all urban transport modes and covered both EU15 and Accession and Central European Countries. It also involved all relevant local or regional stakeholders, including public and private sector organisations and associations of users.

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative aimed to make maximum use of results and knowledge from the previous work and from other projects. In particular it embraced the common indicators being developed in CIVITAS. A substantial proportion of the participants were members of the CIVITAS Forum which helped develop close links between the two projects.

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifProject Timescale

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative lasted for three years and below is a rough outline of the timescale of the project:

  •  
    • June 15th 2004, MAI in Brussels
      Year 1 Final conference & publication of project results.
    • September 28th 2004
      Year Two Launch Workshop at the Maisons des Associations Internationales in Brussels
    • November 2004 - January 2005
      First round of site visits
    • February 2005 – April 2005
      Second round of site visits
    • May 2005
      Final site visits for year two
    • June 29th 2005
      Year 2 Final conference & publication of project results.
    • September 22nd 2005
      Year Three Launch Workshop “Urban Mobility Good Practice in European Cities”
    • November 2005 - January 2006
      First round of site visits (Working groups define data indicators)
    • February 2006 – April 2006
      Second round of site visits (Collation of working group data)
    • May 2006
      Final site visits for year three (Joint analysis of collected data and trends)
    • June 16th 2006
      Year 3 Final conference & publication of project results.
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifProject Management 

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative was managed by a consortium of three companies. These are Transport and Travel Research Ltd (TTR), The International Association of Public Transport (UITP) and the Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe (REC). The details of these organisations are listed below and those interested in finding out more information can click on the relevant company logo below to follow a hyperlink to the company home page:

Transport & Travel Research LTD (TTR)

TTR is a private transport research consultancy based at 4 sites in the UK. Formed in 1991, the company has continued to grow and currently operates with a staff of 37 and a turnover of around €2.8m. The company's mission is:

“Within a commercial environment, to be acknowledged as one of the best transport consultants providing high quality, informative research and advice to transport policy decision makers to make transport systems more sustainable, equitable, efficient and safe to the benefit of our environment, our economy and our society.”

TTR has a wide-ranging portfolio of UK national and local projects covering a variety of transport policy issues from user requirements for telematics systems to mobility issues for disabled people. This is supported by a long participation in leading edge European research for several Directorates General, from Framework 3 to the current Framework 6.

In addition to managing the Urban Transport Benchmarking project, TTR currently runs the CUPID (road pricing) and PLUME (land use and transport research) thematic networks for DG TREN and DG Research. TTR is also involved with a number of ongoing EC research projects such as EDICT (personal rapid transit), TAPESTRY (travel awareness campaigns), CATCH (transport and health) and MATISSE (social exclusion).

For further information please contact TTR at enquiries@ttr-ltd.com or visit website www.ttr-ltd.com.


The International Association of Public Transport

The International Association of Public Transport (UITP) is the world-wide association of urban and regional passenger transport operators, their authorities and suppliers. UITP aims to study all aspects of public transport and mobility in order to promote the development of more efficient and attractive public transport services and gain the maximum benefit from the latest available technology.

UITP has worked with cities around the world on benchmarking the performance of urban transport systems through the Millennium Cities Database, currently followed by the Mobility in Cities Database project. It also co-ordinates the VOYAGER Thematic Network which hosts the ELTIS website containing best practice case studies in local transport across Europe.

For further information please contact: studies@uitp.com or visit website www.uitp.com


The Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe

The Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe (REC) is a non-partisan, non-advocacy, not-for-profit organisation with a mission to assist in solving environmental problems in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE). The Center fulfils this mission by encouraging co-operation among non-governmental organisations, governments, businesses and other environmental stakeholders, by supporting the free exchange of information and by promoting public participation in environmental decision-making.

For further information please contact: info@rec.org or visit website www.rec.org.

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifIndicators & Themes

The Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative researched 6 themes. These themes were organised by working groups and these are listed below:

  • Behavioural and Social Issues in Public Transport
  • City Logistics
  • Cycling
  • Demand Management
  • Public Transport Organisation and Policy
  • Urban Transport for Disabled People

The working group themes were chosen by the project’s participants in order that the project reflected their interests in terms of urban transport systems in cities. The participating cities were also responsible for selecting the data indicators that were used to benchmark the urban transport systems of the cities. These indicators were specific to each working group and aimed to answer the group’s research questions. The participants were aided with the definition and analysis of thematic indicators by their working group rapporteur and expert.

The Common Indicators were being collected by all of the Urban Transport Benchmarking participants and provided a quantitative data set of the general features of each of the participating city’s transport systems. The thematic data indicators are different for each of the working groups and are based strictly around each group's chosen theme.

The working group’s findings are freely available from TTR and were presented at end of year conferences.

 

 Working Groups
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifUrban Transport and Disabled People

The Urban Transport for Disabled People working group was a new working group for year three of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative. During their first site visit to Hasselt, they decided that their research should centre on approaches towards providing transport for disabled people rather than specific engineering. The focus was on the balance between making mainstream public transport accessible and providing specialised services, while also looking at social advantages of different approaches. The Urban Transport for Disabled People working group was led by TTR. The cities participating in the working group were:

  • Aalborg
  • Fife
  • Ile de France (Paris)
  • Mechelen
  • Uppasala

Site visits were made to:

  1. Hasselt, January 12th and 13th 2006
  2. Paris, May 4th and 5th 2006
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifBehavioural and Social Issues in Public Transport

During year one of the initiative the group’s research question involved looking at the effect that public transport marketing has upon travel behaviour with the main focus questioning what can be done to increase the market share of public transport and retain existing customers. In order to collect data to try and answer the research question the group has devised a range of indicators based around the key themes of “knowing the market”, “products and services” and “communication”.

The group narrowed its research during year two of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative and focused upon younger people (aged 10-25) as a target user group.

The third year focused on “How can we influence the travel behaviour of commuters, in order to increase the market share of sustainable modes and retain existing customers?” with a special focus on the sub-urban market. This question was answered using some joint indicators with the Cycling working group. In year three, the Behavioural and Social Issues in Public Transport working group TTR. The cities participating in the working group were; Delft, Dublin, Fife, Nottingham, Paris and Santander.

Site visits were made to:

  • Santander, December 1st and 2nd 2005
  • The Hague, March 23rd and 24th 2006
  • Nottingham, May 18th and 19th 2006
  • Paris, December 2nd and 3rd 2004
  • Brescia, March 14th and 15th 2005
  • Bologna, May 12th and 13th 2005
  • Valencia, December 3rd and 4th 2003
  • Rotterdam, March 18th and 19th 2004
  • Helsinki, April 26th and 27th 2004

 

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifCity Logistics

The City Logistics working group was led by Deutsche Post and supported by TTR. The cities participating in the working group were Aalborg, Bristol, Rome and Genoa. 

During year one of the initiative the group’s research question involved looking at the relationships between cities and freight operators and also looked at the ways cities can balance the often conflicting demands of passenger and freight services. In order to collect data to try and answer the research question the group defined a range of indicators which were based around key issues such as the supply and demand of freight services in the city, the number of freight trips made in the city and the average loading/unloading times.

The group was not as well supported during year two of the initiative and, as a result of an insufficient number of participants, the group’s activities ceased.

Site visits were made to:

  • Aalborg, January 8th and 9th 2004
  • Bristol, March 15th and 16th 2004
  • Rome, May 10th and 11th 2004
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifCycling

In the first year of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative, the group’s research questions focused primarily upon mainstreaming cycling in policy and practice, and identifying how marketing and infrastructure influence cycling usage. The thematic indicators covered a broad spectrum of issues such as modal split, policy objectives, infrastructure, awareness and promotion of cycling.

During year two of the initiative the group chose to focus upon how cities measure and review the effects of their cycling policies, how cycling can be integrated with public transport modes to encourage mutual demand uptake and the marketing techniques that are being used by the cities in the group to engage specific audiences.

The questions to be researched by the group in year three were as follows:

  1. How can Cities Monitor and Evaluate Cycling?
  2. How to encourage intermodality for cyclists and Public Transport users so that both can benefit?

The second of these questions was researched using joint indicators with the Behavioural Issues in Public Transport working group.

In year three, the Cycling working group was led by Velomondial and supported by TTR. The cities participating in the working group were Brescia, Copenhagen, Cycling Scotland, Glasgow, Longon, Malmo and The Hague

Site visits were made to:

  • Santander, December 1st and 2nd 2005
  • The Hague, March 23rd and 24th 2006
  • Malmo, May 8th and 9th 2006
  • Copenhagen, November 11th and 12th 2004
  • Brescia, March 14th and 15th 2005
  • Glasgow, May 12th and 13th 2005
  • Copenhagen, March 18th and 19th 2004
  • Lyon, May 4th and 5th 2004
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifDemand Management

The cities participating in the working group were Merton, Parma, Preston and Sofia.

The group’s research question during year one of the project involved looking at how cities can enforce demand management measures and how they can make these measures acceptable. In order to collect data to try and answer the research question, the group defined a range of indicators which were based around the key themes of “integration of transport and urban planning”, “parking location and regulation”, “parking and congestion charging” and “space restriction/reallocation”.

During year two of the initiative the working group’s activities focused upon land use and transport, parking policies and environmental impacts of demand management. As part of the group’s research during year two of the benchmarking initiative the group added some of the indicators from the PLUME project, which tie in with the land use aspects of demand management. Many of the relevant indicators which were successfully collected by the group in year one of the initiative were retained and redefined and a number of new indicators have been added to relate to the year two topic and to complement the PLUME indicators which will be collected.

In order to meet the interests of the participants in this working group it was planned but the year three topic should cover a mixture of demand management and road safety issues. Suggested topics are listed below, but these were not implemented due to a

  • traffic calming measures/road layout
  • information and education campaigns
  • enforcement campaigns
  • how road accident data are collected, stored, managed and analysed
  • results available for implemented measures
  • specific measures for cyclists and pedestrians
  • road safety measures planning process (e.g. steps, responsibilities, tools, problems)
  • road safety audits and inspections

The group was not as well supported during year three of the initiative and, as a result of an insufficient number of participants, the group’s activities ceased.

Site visits were made to:

  • Preston, February 2006
  • Dublin, November 25th and 26th 2004
  • The Hague, April 14th and 15th 2005
  • Barcelona, January 15th and 16th 2004
  • London, February 26th and 27th 2004
  • Oulu, April 19th and 20th 2004
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifPublic Transport Organisation & Policy

The cities participating in the working group were Athens, Belfast, Berlin, Budapest, Brussels, Dublin, Merseyside, Netherlands Minstry of Transport and Stuttgart.

In year one of the benchmarking initiative the group’s research question involved looking at the financial and organizational aspects of urban transport. In order to collect data to try and answer the research question the group devised a range of indicators based around the key themes of “cost reduction”, “revenue maximization”, “service quality” and “patronage levels”.

During year two of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative the group examined contracts between operators and authorities, which were identified as a key tool to improve the performance of public transport during year one. The group used year two of the initiative to look beyond the benchmarks identified during the first year and to explore practices that account for the best performance levels.

In year three, the Leader and Rapporteur of the Public Transport Organisation and Policy working group was UITP. During this time the group investigated:

  • Fare policy
  • Alternative sources of revenue for public transport operation and development
  • Cost reduction strategies.

Site visits were made to:

  • Rotterdam, January 5th and 6th 2006
  • Berlin, March 13th and 14th 2006
  • Paris March 4th and 5th 2006
  • Madrid, December 13th and 14th 2004
  • Stuttgart, March 7th and 8th 2005
  • Athens, May 5th and 6th 2005
  • Valencia, December 3rd and 4th 2003
  • Copenhagen, March 11th and 12th 2004
  • Merseyside and Dublin, May 18th and 19th 2004

  

 Publications, Reports and Outputs
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifPress Releases & Brochures

The documents below were produced as part of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative.  The documents are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view any of the publications identified below please contact TTR for more information.

Benchmarking Project Brochure Autumn 2005
  • English, German and French languages
Benchmarking Project Brochure Spring 2005
  • English, German and French languages
Benchmarking Year One Results Summary Autumn 2004
  • English version / German version  / French version
Benchmarking Project Brochure Spring 2004
  • English version / German version  / French version
Press Releases
  • Urban Transport Interest Groups Wanted!
Project Flyer
  • English version / German version / French version
Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative Brochure
  • English version / German version / French version
 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifProject Reports

The reports identified below represent the findings of the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative. These reports represent the in-depth results from the 5 thematic working groups and the common indicators that were collected by all participants in the initiative. The documents are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view any of the reports identified below please contact TTR for more information.

Project Final Reports
  • A0: FINAL PROJECT REPORT
  • A1: COMMON INDICATOR REPORT
  • A2: BEHAVIOURAL & SOCIAL ISSUES GROUP REPORT
    • Annexes A2.1: BEHAVIOURAL ANNEX
  • A3: CYCLING WORKING GROUP REPORT
    • Annexes A3.1: CYCLING ANNEX
  • A4: PUBLIC TRANSPORT ORGANISATION & POLICY REPORT
    • Annexes A4.1: PTOP ANNEX
  • A5: URBAN TRANSPORT FOR DISABLE PEOPLE GROUP REPORT
    • Annexes A5.1: URBAN TRANSPORT FOR DISABLE PEOPLE ANNEX
  • INTERESTING PRACTICE & INTERCHANGES
Year 2 Final Reports
  • A0: FINAL PROJECT REPORT
  • A1: COMMON INDICATOR REPORT
    • Annexes A1.1: COMMON INDICATOR DATA ANNEX
  • A2: BEHAVIOURAL & SOCIAL ISSUES IN PUBLIC TRANSPORT REPORT
    • Annexes A2.1: BEHAVIOURAL DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
  • A3: CYCLING WORKING GROUP REPORT 
    • A3.1: CYCLING DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
  • A4: DEMAND MANAGEMENT WORKING GROUP REPORT 
    •  A4.1: DEMAND MANAGEMENT DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK 
  • A5: PUBLIC TRANSPORT ORGANISATION & POLICY REPORT 
    •  A5.1: PTOP DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
  • A6: JOINT WORKING GROUP MEETING REPORT
Year 1 Final Reports
  • A0: FINAL PROJECT REPORT (OVERVIEW OF YEAR 1)
  • A1: COMMON INDICATOR REPORT
    • A1.1: COMMON INDICATOR DATA ANNEX 
    • A1.2: REVIEW OF PREVIOUS INITIATIVES 
  • A2: BEHAVIOURAL & SOCIAL ISSUES IN PUBLIC TRANSPORT REPORT 
    • A2.1: BEHAVIOURAL DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK 
    • A2.2: BEHAVIOURAL SITE VISITS AND CASE STUDIES
  • A3: CITY LOGISTICS WORKING GROUP REPORT 
    • A3.1: CITY LOGISTICS DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK 
    • A3.2: CITY LOGISTICS SITE VISITS AND CASE STUDIES 
  • A4: CYCLING WORKING GROUP REPORT 
    • A4.1: CYCLING DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
    • A4.2: CYCLING SITE VISITS AND CASE STUDIES 
  • A5: DEMAND MANAGEMENT WORKING GROUP REPORT 
    • A5.1: DEMAND MANAGEMENT DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
    • A5.2: DEMAND MANAGEMENT SITE VISITS AND CASE STUDIES 
  • A6: PUBLIC TRANSPORT ORGANISATION & POLICY REPORT
    • A6.1: PTOP DATA COLLECTION HANDBOOK
    • A6.2: PTOP SITE VISITS AND CASE STUDIES 

 

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifBenchmarking Tool

The online benchmarking tool was developed to enable instantaneous graphical comparisons to be made between the indicator data collected by the cities participating in the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative. Representatives from cities not participating in the project were also able to enter their data and benchmark their city's urban transport characteristics against those in the cities involved in the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative.

 

 ecbenchmarking_logo.gifUrban Transport Benchmarking Final Conference, Budapest 2006

The Conference Agenda can be seen below. The documents are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view or obtain a copy of a specific presentation identified below please contact TTR for more information.

Conference Agenda

Supported by: EC DG TREN
Organised by: Transport & Travel Research ltd
Conference Chair: Transport & Travel Research Ltd

Introductions
  • Chairman's Welcome & Overview of year three activities – TTR
  • Urban Transport Benchmarking Year Three – EC DGTREN
Summary of year three working group findings – Part 1
  • Cycling  – Vélo Mondial & TTR
  • Behavioural and Social Issues in Public Transport – TTR
Summary of year three working group findings – Part 2
  • Public Transport Organisation and Policy  – UITP
  • Urban Transport for Disabled People – TTR
Trends from benchmarking
  • Urban Transport Trends in Participant Cities – TTR
Site Presentations
  • Paris: What we gained from Urban Transport Benchmarking,  RATP
  • London: What we gained from Urban Transport Benchmarking, TfL
Integration between working groups
  • Summary of joint working group site visits and integration issues identified by the benchmarking initiative – TTR & Cycling Scotland.
  • Belfast: What we gained from Urban Transport Benchmarking – - Translink
  • Ile de France: What we gained from Urban Transport Benchmarking, - STIF
Guest Presentations
  • The SPICYCLES project – Velo Mondial
  • The UNIACCES project – UNIACCESS project coordinator
Future application of Urban Transport Benchmarking
  • What next for Urban Transport Benchmarking? – TTR
Summary and Close
  • Questions and comments from delegates - Chaired by TTR

Close of Conference