Section Links
CATCH (2003 - 2006)
CATCH (2003 - 2006) was a demonstration project in the European Commission's Life-Environment Programme. It supported the EC's Sixth Environmental Action Programme by promoting sustainable mobility in order to improve air quality.
The website for the above project is no longer maintained.
In the past TTR have project coordinated a high number of projects, and the website has been an important element for disseminating project information. This particularly project has now come to an end and the website is no longer maintained. To prevent the lost of project information, documents & reports the CATCH project has moved here The TTR Project Archive.
If you need any further details please contact TTR (enquiries@ttr-ltd.com)
ContentsCATCHWhat is CATCH / Project PartnersCities - LiverpoolLiverpool - Project Outcomes: Clean Vehicles / Healthy Urban Lifestyles / Movement Strategies / Pollution MonitoringCities - ItalyItaly - Project Outcomes: Feasibility Study / Priorities for Potenza / Limited Traffic Zone Design / Limited Traffic Zone Impacts / Barriers to ImplementationCities - RomaniaRomania - Project Outcomes: LPG Fuel & Vehicles / Vehicle Emission Reduction / Trolleybus Refurbishment / Low Emission Zone / Promotional ActivitiesPublications, Reports & OutputsNewsletters & Brochures / Reports / Conference / Dissemination Events / Ecotravel |
CATCH |
catch.jpgWhat is CATCH?
CATCH was a demonstration project in the European Commission's Life-Environment Programme. It supported the EC's Sixth Environmental Action Programme by promoting sustainable mobility in order to improve air quality. CATCH was implemented in Liverpool (UK), Suceava (Romania) and Potenza (Italy).CATCH adopted an innovative and multi-disciplinary approach to reducing air pollution in Liverpool (UK), driving forward and demonstrating both hard measures, such as the provision of clean buses and new bus services, and soft measures, such as personal travel plans, calorie mapping and the production of new transport policies.
The success of CATCH was evaluated through advanced pollution monitoring techniques and the impact on community health was evaluated by using a Health Impact Assessment (HIA) methodology. Related schemes were also implemented in Romania (Suceava) and Italy (Potenza) and the results are being used for best practice guidance throughout Europe.
The CATCH demonstration project finished in April 2006.
catch.jpgProject Partners
Project co-ordinator: Merseytravel (www.merseytravel.gov.uk)
Partners:
- The City of Liverpool (www.liverpool.gov.uk)
- Arriva (www.arrivanw.co.uk)
- TTR (www.ttr-ltd.com)
- CTP (www.ctpn.it)
- Primar al municipiului Suceava (http://www.primariasv.ro/)
Main subcontractors:
- University of Liverpool (www.liv.ac.uk)
- IMPACT (www.ihia.org.uk)
- ORBIS Consultants Ltd (orbisconsultants@aol.com)
Cities - Liverpool |
catch.jpgLiverpool
Liverpool has a population of around 439,500 and dominates the large metropolitan area of Merseyside (population of 1.4 million). Merseytravel is the Merseyside Passenger Transport Authority and Executive, working in partnership with the five local authorities, including Liverpool City Council. Merseyside has its own suburban rail network and the majority of the bus services operate in a deregulated environment. A new tram service is currently being developed by Merseytravel, with the first of three lines scheduled to open in 2006/7.
Liverpool was the lead city in the CATCH project and the focus for the development and implementation of an innovative approach to transport-related environment policy. A number of demonstration projects were undertaken in Liverpool which focused on:
- technological innovation;
- improved facilities;
- awareness raising; and,
- better information provision regarding transport choices with beneficial environmental impacts.
The findings of these demonstrations were transferred to the project partners in Potenza and Suceava in order to transfer knowledge and experience to Accession Countries and to Southern Europe.
catch.jpgLiverpool - Project Outcomes
Clean Vehicles
Arriva fitted particulate filters to the exhausts of 89 city buses. This reduced emissions of hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide by 90% and particulates by 95%. The potential for using new, cleaner diesel fuels within the bus industry was also assessed. Information on clean fuels and vehicles was made available from the EcoTravel Information Bureau and six electric / hybrid buses were introduced onto a new city centre route all as part of the CATCH project.The CATCH trials have provided a useful demonstration of the potential capabilities of hybrid buses. A total of 6 hybrid buses were introduced onto the City Centre route designed to link several regeneration areas, Liverpool's main shopping centre and main transport nodes, thus improving accessibility within the city centre.
The hybrid buses operating in Liverpool represented the first fleet of its kind in the UK. T he lack of other production orders for manufacturer, due to the hiatus in the market, has meant that the CATCH project's order of 6 vehicles was the sum total of their production in this period. As a result, the CATCH hybrid buses represented all of the product development work in taking the vehicles from prototype to a pre-production model. This product development required significant management time and maintenance support and caused more operational inconvenience than would have been expected with the purchase of a conventional vehicle.
Our demonstration has identified nothing which fundamentally stands against the concept of hybrid vehicles, but has identified several issues which hybrid vehicle manufacturers must overcome if hybrids are to develop into a part of the mainstream bus fleet. As a result, it is clear that more development and evaluation work will be necessary to help the product develop from a niche market with small, one-off orders to a larger, more continuous production base.
The detailed findings from the demonstration of particulate traps on buses in Liverpool have been evaluated in chapters 4 and 5 of the CATCH Evaluation Report .
Healthy / Urban Lifestyles
Liverpool was named the European Capital of Culture 2008 and is undergoing radical structural change motivated by economic regeneration. The challenge now is to encourage both existing and new residents to adopt lifestyles with a low environmental impact.EcoTravel Information Bureau
This one-stop shop provides both individuals and businesses with all the information that they may require about clean, healthy and sustainable travel in Liverpool. The bureau combines the work of Merseytravel and Merseyside TravelWise and the EcoTravel website can be found at http://www.ecotravel.org.uk/
Community Mobility Plans
These have demonstrated to individuals living in central Liverpool that there are alternatives to the private car. Merseytravel and TravelWise have worked closely with property developers on the design of proposed housing schemes to ensure that they accommodate the needs of pedestrians, cyclists and public transport users.
Individualised Marketing
The CATCH healthy travel promotion aimed to encourage greater use of sustainable transport for trips to the city centre through the use of one-to-one contact. The Aigburth/Grassendale area in South East Liverpool was selected as the target area for implementation of the project. Surveys of households were conducted with the results analysing what motivating factors could be drawn on to encourage change. A tailored marketing package was then sent to households with support phone calls encouraging use of incentives and information. Journey planners were produced including appropriate journey details and also health or environmental or stress related benefits according to the interest of that individual.
Healthy Travel Incentives
CATCH also introduced the innovative concept of calorie mapping. This has provided a map of the city centre and some examples of journeys that could be made by foot. The number of calories burnt by making these journeys is displayed, providing a completely new incentive for residents to travel greater distances by foot.
The evaluation of the Healthy Urban Lifestyles demonstration projects can be found in chapter 7 of the CATCH Evaluation Report .
Movement Strategies
The Liverpool City Centre Movement Strategy (CCMS) is a comprehensive long term programme to improve transport infrastructure in Liverpool. Integral to the project is the reduction of road traffic in the city centre, the improvement of conditions for pedestrians and the upgrading of infrastructure for public transport. CATCH added value to the CCMS by strengthening partnership and funding a detailed design study aimed at making access to an important commercial district easier for sustainable modes of transport such as walking or cycling. Following this a number of measures have been approved including "all red" pedestrian areas and better pedestrian crossings, better infrastructure for buses, footpath improvements and improved cycling lanes and cycling parking provision.ECOtravel day was held on the 5th June 2004 in Lord Street (Liverpool City Centre) and this was repeated in 2005. The day was used to highlight the benefits of sustainable travel and showcase the work of the ECOtravel Information Bureau and CATCH. The day also launched the city wide Green Transport Festival (GTF). The event was advertised through Merseytravel, on local radio, on the ECOtravel website and through many other means. Over 1000 people attended the event which showcased the new Honda IMA, a Toyota Prius and Liverpool City Councils LPG fuelled delivery van. The public commented on the fact that the exhibitions from Merseytravel, Liverpool City Council, TravelWise, The University of Liverpool, Merseyside Cycle Campaign and others were very useful and informative and they would welcome more events in the future. The profile of the ECOtravel bureau was raised and the CATCH project was highlighted. Surveys carried out at the two ECOtravel days revealed an annual increase in public awareness of the ECOtravel campaign and the hybrid buses operating on the new City Centre bus route.
The full evaluation of this aspect of the Liverpool demonstration projects can be found in chapter 7 of the CATCH Evaluation Report .
Pollution Monitoring
CATCH introduced advanced and innovative pollution monitoring techniques developed by the University of Liverpool 's Centre for Intelligent Monitoring Systems (CIMS). A CCTV-based system using light scattering techniques was used and cameras were positioned at fixed sites within the city and on the buses themselves. The monitoring lead to the mapping of high concentrations of particulates within Liverpool city centres and identified the times at which pollution was at its greatest.Monitoring with this system on Car Free Day in September 2003 and 2004 recorded a significant fall in the level of particulates in the air by between 50 and 75% when traffic was removed from a particular area. This drop in particulate concentration was outside the day to day variations caused by changing weather and other ambient conditions and suggests that the 'car free day' did have a measurable and positive impact on air quality in the immediate locality of the road closure.
The full evaluation of the pollution monitoring component of the CATCH demonstration is available in chapter 8 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Cities - Italy |
catch.jpgItaly
Standing at 820m above sea level, Potenza is the chief town of the Basilicata region and is situated 150 km south east of Naples . The town has a population of 70,000 (110,000 including surrounding districts) and t he Italian project partner, CTP, is the regional public transport provider in the region of Naples.
Through CATCH a feasibility study for a number of urban transport improvements was undertaken in the city of Potenza . Proposed measures to be included in the feasibility study were:
-
To organise a new and more efficient integrated transport system;
-
To encourage the use of public transport and to decrease traffic;
-
To define interchange points for public transport in the city;
-
To use ecological vehicles and fuel for the public transport service which enters the ZTL;
-
To develop a traffic plan and study the possibility of establishing emission free areas through Limited Traffic Zones (ZTL); and,
-
To disseminate information in order to increase citizen awareness about the causes of the pollution and the damaging effects that it has on health.
catch.jpgItaly- Project Outcomes
Feasibility Study
The feasibility study for the implementation of the project in Potenza was conducted around a project scenario of the Limited Traffic Zone defined in conjunction with the town's municipal administration as follows: • Definition of the location of Limited Traffic Zone boundaries, of its regulations and of the access and exiting roads;
- Definition of the location of areas and route to be assigned as pedestrian only areas;
- Implementation of Park and Ride facilities;
- Definition of the new circulation scheme in the Limited Traffic Zone coherent with the new pedestrian areas and with objectives to improve vehicle circulation, limit access to the ZTL and contain conflict points between vehicles and pedestrians;
- Reorganisation of parking in the historical centre in order to maximize parking supply on secondary roads and reduce it on main roads; and,
- The reorganisation of local public transport.
As a result of this feasibility study a number of Priorities were developed for improving the current transport situation in Potenza
Prorities for Potenza
As a result of the CATCH feasibility study the following priorities were developed for Potenza :• Promote the pedestrian component in the city centre.
- Limit the number of vehicle movements entering the historical centre of Potenza .
- Reduce long term parking supply by increasing the parking capacity of the zone and the accessibility to short term parking facilities.
- Promote the use of Public Transport, reducing vehicle access to the city and managing parking demand in the most congested areas of the city centre.
These priorities were reflected in the design of the Limited Traffic Zone (TLZ)
Limited Traffic Zone Design
When defining the Limited Traffic Zone (LTZ) in Potenza, the following criteria were considered:
- The extension of the historical centre and the distribution of the principal activities;
- The pre-existence of small pedestrian areas (e.g. Via Pretoria);
- The transport accessibility and the possible circulation directions; and,
- Geographical area.
- The result was a defined zone with limited access to traffic which included:
- Pedestrianised areas;
- Park and Ride sites;
- Changes to the exiting traffic routes to improve traffic flows;
- Re-organising the parking supply to maximize short-stay capacity; and
-
Improved provision for public transport alternatives
Limited Traffic Zone Impacts
Modelling the planned changes to the city of Potenza in order to accommodate the Limited Traffic Zone indicated that there would be:
- A 55% decrease in the number of private vehicle movements into the historical centre in both the morning peak and an even greater decrease in the afternoon peak hours;
- An increase in public transport use (from the current 10-15% to 40-50% in the project scenario) – increased use of the escalators equal to 400% due to Park and Ride and an increase of passengers on elevators achieving the full capacity ;
- An improved level of service in terms of average speed and congestion in the historical centre which is also apparent on the entire individual transport network.
- A reduction in the emission of atmospheric pollutants from traffic in the limited traffic zone by 50% in the morning peak hour and more than 90% in the afternoon peak (see below):
For a number of reasons it was not possible to implement the LTZ.
Barriers to Implementation
Despite the fact that the estimated environmental impacts appear to be highly beneficial to the local environment within the town, political changes have prevented delivery of the Limited Traffic Zone. In spite of repeated and forceful efforts by all partners to change the minds of the new local administration, this included the proposed support programme of awareness raising campaigns.This situation leads us to the lesson that a strong verbal commitment and related action is not enough on its own to ensure continued support from key partners and that such partners need to be formally involved through contractual commitments in EC demonstration projects.
Further information is available in chapter 10 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Cities - Romania |
catch.jpgRomania
The city of Suceava has a population of 118,500 and is located 450km north of the capital, Bucharest . The local authority, Suceava Municipality , own and finance the local transport company, who provide public transport within the city.
The aim of Suceava was to follow the project measures implemented Liverpool whilst bearing in mind Suceava's local economy and financial situation. A local consortium was set up to implement CATCH measures consisting of municipality officials, representatives from the County Council, the Prefecture, the Environmental Protection Agency, Local Transport Company and Traffic Police.
The CATCH project work was conducted against the background of a rapid increase in car ownership in Suceava - from 150 cars per 1000 inhabitants at the start of the project to an expected value of 250 by the end of 2005. This is expected to lead to increased congestion if messages relating to rational use of transport modes are not followed by Suceava's citizens.
catch.jpgRomania - Project Outcomes
LPG Fuel & Vehicles
Arriva fitted particulate filters to the exhausts of 89 city buses. This reduced emissions of hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide by 90% and particulates by 95%. The potential for using new, cleaner diesel fuels within the bus industry was also assessed. Information on clean fuels and vehicles was made available from the EcoTravel Information Bureau and six
Two LPG cars purchased were purchased by the municipality in order to promote environmentally friendly vehicles. LPG was chosen because electric and hybrid vehicles are still expensive and not accessible by all, whereas LPG vehicles represent a mid term solution for emission reductions in the city of Suceava and in other cities from Romania .
Over the last 2 years the LPG car travelled around 60,000 km on municipality business, with a consumption level of 10l/100km giving an estimated use of 6000 litres of LPG. The emission reduction for this municipal vehicle only is a saving of 10.2 kg CO2 (5.1 kg/year). Based on this reduction in emissions and satisfactory operational performance another LPG fuelled car manufactured by a local car manufacturer, was purchased in June 2005.
Further details are available in chapter 9 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Vehicle Emission Reductions
The implementation phase of the CATCH project in Suceava included the installation of emission reduction systems on 5 cars in the municipality's car fleet and 10 Euro 2 minibuses in the local public transport company's fleet.
The emissions reductions for the system on a Euro 2 vehicle were good, with a 36% reduction in CO and an 89% reduction in HC. Even though emission reductions were good, new Euro 3 vehicles available in the city are already equipped with this type of system and are considered more accessible and more efficient for emission reductions than re-equipping the older vehicles that are already in operation.
Fitting particulate filters to municipal vehicles is not a solution for reducing traffic emissions as the results from these experiments were not particularly good, but the fitting of particulate filters to all existing minibuses could be a mid term solution for the improvement of air quality in the city centre as these vehicles responded better to the technology.
Further details are available in chapter 9 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Trolleybus Refurbishment
Ten trolleybuses operated by the local transport company were refurbished and re-entered service to replace 10 existing old Euro 0 buses with poor emissions performance. The implementation occurred relatively early in the CATCH project, thus allowed 2 years for the evaluation study to quantify the level of reduction at the end of CATCH Project.
The replacement of buses with refurbished trolleybuses is equivalent to a 100% reduction in emissions at point of use and electric vehicles are seen as environmentally friendly modes, although trolleybuses are restricted to a fixed network and so not as flexible as other public transport modes.
The level of emission reduction is considered to be very good when compared with the cost of the system installation. The measure is considered to be a long term solution applicable in Suceava and also all cities in Romania where trolleybuses remain a common mode of transport.
Further details are available in chapter 9 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Low Emission Zone
The extension of the low emission zone (LEZ) occurred very early in the project and was extremely well received by the local population. The low emission zone area within Suceava city centre was extended by converting a section of Stefan cel Mare Street into a pedestrian only area and closing the main part of Stefan cel Mare Street between 7.30 pm and 6.30 am weekdays and all the time during weekends. By doing this the area has been used heavily for municipal events and has been considered a success by the city and local population.
The transformation of Stefan cel Mare Street into a pedestrian area at the weekend influenced a change in public attitudes and enabled people to cycle, walk and car share. The extension of the low emission zone and access restrictions within the city delivered a reduction in traffic emissions and an improvement in air quality especially in the city centre. The further extension of the LEZ is considered to be a long term solution for improving the quality of life in the city centre.
Further details are available in chapter 9 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Promotional Activities
Extensive promotion was carried out by Suceava as part of the overall CATCH project and within each individual technical measure. Promotional activities include:
- LPG was extensively promoted in Suceava . Results indicated that in the last 2 years of the CATCH project there are approximately 574 LPG vehicles registered in Suceava, of which 219 were newly registered during the 2 year project period. There was also an increase in the number of filling stations selling LPG from 3-9.
- Strong links were developed between Suceava Municipality and schools, high schools, public institutes and private companies to promote environmentally friendly ways of travelling, clean fuels and LPG cars. Posters, brochures and folders were also distributed widely.
- Events were held in the low emission zone area to promote it and the positive impact it has on the quality of life in the city, pedestrian facilities, distribution of CATCH promotional material, car free days and environmentally friendly ways to travel.
- A questionnaire was conducted to establish the public's reaction to the project and measures proposed by the study . Results showed that respondents generally agreed with the CATCH measures. Non-users of public transport and private car owners were less satisfied with the transformation of a main traffic street into a pedestrianised area.
Further details are available in chapter 9 of the CATCH Evaluation Report
Publications, Reports and Outputs |
catch.jpgNewsletters & Brochures
The documents below were produced as part of the CATCH Project. The documents are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view any of the publications please contact TTR for more information.
Newsletters
- CATCH News Issue 4
- CATCH News Issue 3
- CATCH News Issue 2
- CATCH News Issue 1
Poster / Banner
- Banner
- Poster 1
- Poster 2
catch.jpgReports & Publications
The results from CATCH have been reported in three separate documents; a non technical summary of key outcomes, a best practice guide and a technical evaluation of the whole project. The documents are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view any of the publications please contact TTR for more information
Final Reports
- Summary Report (non-technical)
- Best Practice Report (technical)
- Evaluation Report (technical)
CATCH Papers
- Finnegan, S; Tickell, G and Booth, K (2004) Sensitivity in the operation of conventional and alternatively fuelled Public Service Vehicles on Merseyside. Proceedings of the Tenth International Conference on Urban Transport and the Environment in the 21st Century. Urban Transport 2004. Dresden, Germany.
- Finnegan, S; Tickell, G and Booth, K (2004) A Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of Alternative Fuels in Transport Operation. Proceedings of the International Conference on Transportation Systems Planning and Operation 2 p.559-569. Indian Institute of Technology, Madras, India.
- The CATCH Project, Clean Accessible Transport for Community Health - Booth.K, Hall.D and Lewis.A (2004).
- The Foresight Vehicle Initiative, comprehensive Health Impact Assessment (HIA) and proposals for the 'CATCH' HIA - Abrahams.D (2003).
CATCH Reports
- The Route to Cleaner Buses: A Guide to operating cleaner, low carbon buses - Energy Saving Trust (2003). .
- Liverpool City Centre Movement Strategy (Summary), Liverpool City Council (2004).
CATCH contributed reports
- Transportenergy best practice guide for the clean operation of buses.
catch.jpgConferences / Dissemination Events
The following presentations are not stored online, therefore not directly accessible, however if you would like to view any of the presentations please contact TTR for more information.
- Brussels, March 17th 2005
- Liverpool : The World in One City - Huw Jenkins, Liverpool City Council
- CATCH Project Partner: Arrive North West & Wales– Nigel Cross, Arriva
- The CATCH Project in Suceava – Dan Dura, Suceava Municipality
- Evaluating the CATCH project – Alan Lewis , TTR
- LIFE & CATCH - Santiago URQUIJO ZAMORA , Desk Officer LIFE Unit
- Liverpool , June 28th – 29th 2005
- June 28th 2006
- Introduction to European Policy and Impact on Transport on Merseyside – Neil Scales,
- Merseytravel LIFE+ New Perspectives – Robbie Craig, DEFRA
- Introduction to CATCH – Dr Karen Booth, Merseytravel
- Health Impact Assessment - Alex Scott-Samuel ,
- International Health Impact Assessment Consortium Environmental Quality and the Poor: An Unjust Link? – Dr Gordon Mitchell, University of Leeds
- CATCH: Can it deliver health benefits? - Debbie Abrahams & Cathal Doyle, International Health Impact Assessment Consortium
- Does the health sector take transport, health and accessibility seriously? - Julia Taylor, Liverpool Healthy Cities
- Do we need to be regulating the bus market in the UK ? – Neil Scales, Merseytravel
- Clean, low carbon transport: the Government perspective – Mark Schuck, DfT
- Low Cost Solutions are part of the answer... - Colin Matthews, Energy Savings Trust
- There must be something more? - Jonathan Murray, Sustainable Transport Solutions Network
- Future vehicle technology across Europe: Experience of biogas for vehicles in West Sweden - Bernt Svensén, Biogas West, Gothenburg.
- Transport, Environment and Health: the links and the options - Francesca Racioppi, World Health Organization
- June 29th 2006
- Smarter Choices: changing the way we travel – Lyn Sloman, Transport for Quality of Life
- Changing the Way We Travel in Merseyside – Sarah Dewar, Merseytravel
- Is it true that cultural differences demand different approaches? – Dan Dura, Suceava Municipality
- Darlington: A Town on The Move – Greg McDougall, Darlington Borough Council
- Psychology and Change: Change mechanisms and communications strategies – John Porter, Interactions
- Improving Urban Air Quality – Stephen Joseph, Transport 2000 A different approach to the problem - Valentina Russo, CTP
- From Acronyms to Action – Tom McCabe, Liverpool City Council
- Local Air Quality Management And Regeneration – Andrew Whittles, Greenwich Borough Council
- How Can Transport Contribute to Future Air Quality Improvements? – Alan Lewis, TTR
- Urban Regeneration in Europe – Dr Andrew Jones, Birkbeck College University of London
- How is Liverpool facing the Challenge of Regeneration – Dave Boyer, Liverpool City Council
- What do we need to consider to deliver a more sustainable city? – Peter Mynors, Capita Symonds
- Regeneration and the sustainable movement of people – Tom Parker, TTR Within CATCH
- June 28th 2006
catch.jpgECOTravel
ECOtravel was formed as part of CATCH and is the one-stop information bureau for both business and the public which aims to raise awareness of sustainable travel, alternative fuels and the environment on Merseyside. The Ecotravel website (www.ecotravel.org.uk) is no longer available - for more information contact Merseyside.

